When you’re hurt in Maine—whether it’s a highway crash, a dangerous property fall, or a life-changing medical error—the lawyer you pick can shape everything that follows: how quickly evidence gets preserved, how hard an insurer pushes back, and whether your case gets treated like a real trial risk or a quick “numbers file.”

How we built this April 2026 list

We focused on publicly available, verifiable indicators—bar admissions, peer-reviewed ratings, and recognized legal publications/directories—rather than repeating the same bios word-for-word. Examples of sources include Super Lawyers profiles, Martindale-Hubbell ratings, Inner Circle of Advocates listings, ABA recognitions, and Lawdragon’s published guides. 

Quick “fit” guide (pick the right type of attorney)

• Catastrophic injuries / medical malpractice / complex causation: look for a firm that routinely litigates high-damages claims and can fund experts.
• Wrongful death: look for lawyers experienced with estate mechanics and damages unique to death claims.
• Cases likely to be disputed hard (liability fights, contested medical issues): trial readiness matters.
• Cases where communication is the biggest stressor: pick someone known for responsiveness and clear process.

Top 5 personal injury attorneys in Maine (April 2026)

1) Peter Thompson — Peter Thompson & Associates (Portland and statewide)

Peter Thompson remains our #1 pick for April 2026 because he combines long-running plaintiff-side focus with consistent, verifiable peer recognition. His Super Lawyers profile lists him as licensed in Maine since 1994, and shows selection to Super Lawyers (2007–2025). 

On the firm side, the Super Lawyers law firm profile lists Peter Thompson & Associates as a top-rated firm for plaintiff personal injury and notes multiple Maine office locations, supporting a statewide footprint rather than a single-office practice. 

Best fit for: serious injury cases where early investigation, structured medical proof, and a litigation-forward approach can change settlement value.

2) Benjamin “Ben” Gideon — Gideon Asen (Lewiston/Portland)

If your case requires heavy lifting—major damages, difficult liability, or medical negligence—Ben Gideon stands out for national-level recognition in plaintiff consumer practice. Lawdragon’s published 2026 guide includes Benjamin “Ben” Gideon (Gideon Asen, Portland, Maine) in its “500 Leading Plaintiff Consumer Lawyers” list. 

Gideon Asen’s own firm bio also highlights his plaintiff-side focus and recognition, giving prospective clients a starting point for evaluating fit for serious-injury and med-mal matters. 

Best fit for: catastrophic injury, medical malpractice, wrongful death, and complex cases that may need significant expert work.

3) Terry Garmey — Garmey Law (Portland)

Terry Garmey is a fixture in Maine trial practice, and his Inner Circle listing shows Status: Emeritus along with Portland office details. 
His firm bio describes decades of plaintiff-side work and emphasizes a history of large verdicts, which—while marketing language—still signals a practice built around taking cases to trial rather than avoiding the courtroom. 

Best fit for: high-stakes injury litigation where courtroom credibility and trial posture can move insurers.

4) Rachel Okun — Okun Law PLLC (Falmouth/Greater Portland)

Rachel Okun’s Super Lawyers profile lists her as licensed in Maine since 2014 and shows selection to Rising Stars (2018–2024). 
The American Bar Association’s “On the Rise” page for 2025 also describes her as founder of Okun Law and highlights her leadership and service within the profession. 
Okun Law’s website describes a Maine-wide personal injury practice (auto collisions, dog bites, premises liability, and more), which can be especially relevant for everyday-but-serious injury cases. 

Best fit for: clients who want a focused plaintiff PI practice with strong communication and a modern, hands-on approach—especially in the Greater Portland area.

5) Mark E. Dunlap — Peter Thompson & Associates (Portland)

For cases that turn on motion practice, disputed expert issues, or high-pressure negotiation, Mark Dunlap is worth noting for verifiable peer-review credentials. His Martindale profile includes an AV Preeminent® rating entry and states he “got this award in 2026.” 
A Lawyers.com profile also places him at Peter Thompson & Associates and notes long licensure history, supporting depth of experience. 

Best fit for: cases where careful lawyering, case framing, and pressure-testing the defense position matter as much as headline-grabbing marketing.

Maine deadline snapshot (don’t wait to investigate)

Two deadlines come up constantly in Maine injury consults:

• General civil limitations period: Maine’s general rule provides six years for civil actions (with exceptions). 
• Wrongful death: Maine’s wrongful death statute states an action must be commenced within three years after the decedent’s death (with a homicide-related exception spelled out in the statute). 

(There are exceptions and special rules—especially for governmental entities—so this is a starting point, not a substitute for advice.)

A simple way to “interview” a PI firm before you sign

If you want this page to convert, these questions help readers take action:

1. Who will actually handle my case day-to-day?
2. What evidence do you need from me in the next 7 days?
3. Do you expect a liability dispute—or a damages dispute—or both?
4. How do you handle experts and case costs?
5. What’s your communication cadence (weekly updates, portal, calls)?