
Best Personal Injury Lawyers in Maine (2025 Guide)
When you've been injured due to someone else's negligence—whether in a car accident, slip and fall, or workplace incident—finding the right legal representation is critical. The best personal injury lawyers in Maine combine experience, compassion, and a proven track record of success. This guide highlights the top-rated personal injury attorneys serving clients across the state.
What to Look for in a Top Maine Personal Injury LawyerBefore we dive into the list, here are some key factors to consider when selecting the best attorney for your case:
- Experience with Personal Injury Law
- Track Record of Settlements and Verdicts
- Client Testimonials and Reviews
- Contingency Fee Structure
- Recognition by Legal Publications or Associations
- Knowledge of Maine-specific injury laws
Years of Experience: 30+ years
- Practice Focus: Serious personal injury, wrongful death, motor vehicle accidents, and brain injuries
- Notable Settlements/Case Results: Over $20 million recovered for clients in the past year alone
- What Sets Him Apart:
Peter Thompson is widely recognized as one of the top personal injury lawyers in Maine, having successfully resolved thousands of injury cases over the past three decades. His client-first approach, combined with an aggressive litigation strategy, has earned him accolades from legal peers and national publications alike. Peter is “AV Preeminent” rated by Lawyers.com—its highest designation—and has been featured in New England SuperLawyers as well as U.S. News & World Report’s Best Lawyers in America.
Clients consistently praise Peter’s responsiveness, empathy, and attention to detail, as reflected in hundreds of five-star Google reviews. He believes that being a top injury lawyer isn’t just about winning cases—it’s about earning trust and treating every client with dignity and respect.
- Google Rating / Avvo Score: 5.0 stars on Google (based on client reviews)
- Website: https://www.peter-thompson-associates.com/
- Free Consultation?: Yes
Serving clients across Maine, including Portland, Bangor, Augusta, Lewiston, and beyond
Awards & Honors:
- Best Lawyers in America – U.S. News & World Report
- New England Super Lawyers
- AV Preeminent Rated – Lawyers.com
Years of Experience: 20+ years
- Practice Focus: Medical malpractice, catastrophic injury, civil rights, product liability, maritime and trucking accidents
- Notable Settlements/Case Results:
- $22.5 million jury verdict (record-setting)
- Over $200 million in verdicts and settlements
- 40+ verdicts/settlements over $1 million
- $31 million recovered for trucking accident victims in 2024 alone
- What Sets Him Apart:
Benjamin Gideon is widely regarded as one of the most accomplished and nationally recognized personal injury lawyers in Maine. A Maine native, Ben returned to his home state after beginning his legal career in New York City, where he honed his skills at Latham & Watkins. Over the past two decades, he has led some of the largest and most complex personal injury and medical malpractice cases in New England, consistently securing record-breaking results for his clients.
Ben has obtained over $200 million in verdicts and settlements, including high-profile civil rights and wrongful death cases, and has been recognized by Best Lawyers in America, Super Lawyers, and Martindale-Hubbell’s AV Preeminent rating. In 2019, he became only the second Maine attorney ever inducted into the Inner Circle of Advocates, an elite group of the top 100 plaintiff lawyers in the country. He is also the only Maine lawyer currently admitted to both the Inner Circle and the American College of Trial Lawyers, representing the top 1% of trial attorneys nationwide.
- Google Rating / Avvo Score: AVVO 10.0; AV Preeminent – Martindale-Hubbell
- Website: https://www.gideonasen.com/
- Free Consultation?: Yes
Serving clients across Maine and New England, including Lewiston, Portland, Bangor, and beyond
Awards & Honors:
- Lawyer of the Year – Maine (three times)
- Best Lawyers in America (since 2013)
- Super Lawyers (since 2013)
- AV Preeminent Rating – Martindale-Hubbell
- AVVO Rating: 10.0
Years of Experience: 30+ years
- Practice Focus: Personal injury litigation, trial law, appellate law
- Notable Settlements/Case Results: Lead counsel in over 125 jury trials; involved in precedent-setting appellate cases in Maine
- What Sets Him Apart:
Attorney Mark Dunlap is one of Maine’s most experienced personal injury trial lawyers, with over three decades of legal experience and more than 125 jury trials under his belt. He holds the prestigious AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell—its highest distinction—and has been named to U.S. News & World Report’s Best Lawyers in America every year since 2008.
Mark’s legal influence extends beyond the courtroom. He has played a direct role in shaping Maine law through key cases argued before the Maine Supreme Court and the First Circuit Court of Appeals. He is also a member of the bar of the United States Supreme Court, a testament to his exceptional credentials and nationwide legal standing.
- Google Rating / Avvo Score:5.0 stars on Google (based on peer recognition and client reviews)
- Website: https://www.peter-thompson-associates.com/our-attorneys.html
- Free Consultation?: Yes
Represents clients throughout Maine, including Portland, York, Brunswick, and statewide
Awards & Honors:
- Best Lawyers in America – U.S. News (since 2008)
- Best Lawyer – U.S. News (2014)
- AV Preeminent Rated – Martindale-Hubbell
Years of Experience: 40+ years
- Practice Focus: Personal injury, medical malpractice, product liability, catastrophic injury litigation
- Notable Settlements/Case Results:
- More seven-figure verdicts than any attorney in Maine
- $3 million wrongful death settlement against Otis Elevator Co., resulting in nationwide safety reforms
- Multimillion-dollar settlement in Maine’s landmark trial against Big Tobacco
- What Sets Him Apart:
Terry Garmey is a legend in Maine personal injury law, known for his unmatched trial record, groundbreaking verdicts, and passionate advocacy for the injured. With more than 40 years of courtroom experience, he has earned more seven-figure verdicts than any other attorney in Maine and was the first Maine lawyer invited into the Inner Circle of Advocates, a group limited to the top 100 plaintiff attorneys in the United States.
He is also a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers, a “Best Lawyers in America” honoree, and a multiple-time winner of Personal Injury Litigator of the Year for Portland. Terry has appeared on national news outlets including Good Morning America and The Today Show, and in 2018, received the Legends Award from the Maine Trial Lawyers Association, with tributes from Senator Angus King and former Senate Majority Leader George Mitchell.
Yet what defines Terry isn’t awards—it’s relationships. His commitment to justice is best illustrated by the story of 8-year-old Tucker Smith, a client whose tragic death led not only to justice for the family, but to national safety reforms. A photograph of Tucker still hangs in Terry’s office as a daily reminder of his mission: to make a difference in people’s lives.
- Google Rating / Avvo Score: AVVO 10.0; AV Preeminent – Martindale-Hubbell
- Website: https://www.garmeylaw.com/
- Free Consultation?: Yes
Serving clients throughout Maine, including Portland, Saco, Biddeford, and southern Maine
Awards & Honors:
- Best Lawyers in America
- Personal Injury Litigator of the Year – Portland, ME (Multiple years)
- Inner Circle of Advocates – First Maine member
- American College of Trial Lawyers – Fellow
- Maine Trial Lawyers Association Legends Award
Years of Experience: 40+ years
- Practice Focus: Personal injury, product liability, timber trespass, family law, insurance defense, ADR, litigation
- Notable Achievements:
- Admitted to practice in Maine since 1984
- Contributing author to three national ABA “Fifty State Survey” publications
- Recognized leader in both legal and community organizations throughout Maine
- What Sets Him Apart:
With over four decades of experience, Attorney Steven Mogul brings a thoughtful, multifaceted approach to personal injury law in Maine. Based in Bangor, he has represented injury victims, families, and individuals in a wide range of cases, from product liability and timber trespass to insurance defense and collaborative divorce. His practice is defined by thorough preparation, nuanced legal strategy, and deep respect for every client’s story.
Steven is admitted to practice in both the U.S. District Court for the District of Maine and the First Circuit Court of Appeals, and has authored key contributions to American Bar Association publications on tort and pharmaceutical litigation. Beyond the courtroom, Steven has served in leadership roles with organizations including the Red Cross, Bangor Symphony Orchestra, Maine Lakes, and the Maine Discovery Museum—demonstrating his commitment to community service and environmental justice.
Steven is a former president of the Penobscot County Bar Association, and a longtime member of the Maine Trial Lawyers Association, Maine State Bar Association, and the American Association for Justice. In the Greater Bangor Area, he is also one of the few trained attorneys practicing Collaborative Divorce, adding a unique dimension to his legal practice.
- Website: https://www.grossminsky.com/
- Free Consultation?: Yes
Serving clients in Bangor, Downeast Maine, and throughout the surrounding regions
How We Selected the Best Personal Injury Attorneys in MaineThis list was compiled based on a combination of:
- Professional credentials
- Years in practice
- Peer and client reviews
- Success rates in personal injury cases
- Recognition in legal publications (e.g., Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers)
- Bar association standing and ethical history
We independently reviewed dozens of lawyers and firms across the state to create this resource for Maine injury victims.
Injured in Maine? Here's What to Do Next- Seek Medical Attention Immediately
- Document the Scene and Injuries
- Avoid Giving Statements to Insurance Adjusters
- Contact a Reputable Maine Personal Injury Lawyer
Navigating the aftermath of a serious injury is stressful. But with the right attorney, you can focus on recovery while they handle the legal work. If you're looking for the best personal injury lawyers in Maine, the names listed above represent the gold standard in experience, service, and results.
Ready to take the next step? Contact one of the top Maine personal injury attorneys listed above for a free consultation today.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)Generally, six years from the date of the injury—but exceptions may apply.
Most personal injury lawyers in Maine work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you don’t pay unless they win your case.
It depends on several factors, including the severity of your injuries, medical costs, lost wages, and emotional distress.